Criticism of the Swedish Coast Guard for taking a mouth swab despite the fact that the measure was disproportionate. Also statements on the prerequisites for taking such a sample when the sentence for the offence in question is usually a day fine
Summary of the decision: The Swedish Coast Guard conducted a body search in the form of a mouth swab on a man suspected of an offence against the Fisheries Act (SFS 1993:787). He and his 10-year-old son were fishing with rods in an area in which fishing was prohibited during certain periods. Although imprisonment is included in the range of punishment for such an offence, the usual sentence is a low day fine.
Under previous legislation, taking a mouth swab in order to register a suspect’s DNA profile was permitted if the offence was punishable by imprisonment, i.e., if the sanction in the case in question could be expected to be other than a fine. The law was changed in July 2025, among other things in an effort to increase the number of samples and registrations, and it is now sufficient for imprisonment to be in the range of punishment for the offence in question. However, according to the legislative history, some additional circumstance justifying sampling ought to be required in cases involving a minor offence for which the sentence is usually a fine. According to the legislative history, with regard to a minor offence, taking a sample may be justified if, for example, the case involves reoffending or links to organised crime. So, the legislators’ intention in introducing this amendment was not to encourage sampling as a matter of routine as soon as the letter of the law allows.
In this case, there were no additional circumstances that could justify sampling and, in the opinion of the Chief Parliamentary Ombudsman, it is clear that this was not the type of situation that the extended opportunity to take samples was intended to address. According to the Chief Parliamentary Ombudsman, in this case it cannot be considered proportionate for the Swedish Coast Guard to take a sample, nor were their legal grounds for doing so. The Swedish Coast Guard is criticised accordingly.