Criticism of the Swedish Schools Inspectorate for asking a question about individuals’ congregational affiliation during a review of a faith-based independent school
Summary of the decision: The Swedish Schools Inspectorate conducted a quality review of a faith-based independent school. In conducting its review, the Swedish Schools Inspectorate asked a question about possible links between members of the school’s management group, including whether they were members of the same congregation.
The Chief Parliamentary Ombudsman notes that answering this question could reveal whether the respondent belonged to a given congregation, and thus divulge their religious opinion. The question therefore arises of whether the agency’s processing involved coercing an individual to divulge their opinion in a religious context in contravention of Article 2 of Chapter 2 of the Instrument of Government (1974:152).
The Swedish Schools Inspectorate requested this information pursuant to a provision of the Education Act (SFS 2010:800), under which the person under an obligation to provide information is expected to answer the agency’s questions truthfully even when the agency has not issued an injunction, and otherwise risk being injuncted to do so under penalty of a fine.
In light of the above, it is the opinion of the Chief Parliamentary Ombudsman that, when the question concerning membership of a congregation was asked, it could have been construed as the kind of coercion to divulge an opinion that is prohibited under the constitution. It is important that public institutions do not act in a manner that gives this impression. The Chief Parliamentary Ombudsman is therefore of the opinion that the question should not have been asked and he criticises the Swedish Schools Inspectorate accordingly.